Un

I remember the first time I surfaced from what the game calls a "story mission" and found myself genuinely puzzled. There I was, a new diver in this beautifully rendered underwater world, accompanied only by my AI companion, expecting some grand narrative to unfold. Instead, what I got was perhaps the most peculiar approach to storytelling I've encountered in modern gaming. The missions themselves are surprisingly brief—I'd estimate about 70% of them wrap up within 3-5 minutes of diving. Several times, I found myself thinking "surely there must be more," only to realize the mission had actually concluded. It creates this strange rhythm where you spend hours exploring freely, only to be rewarded with narrative segments that feel more like extended tutorials than proper story progression.

What makes this particularly confusing is the game's structure. You'll spend what feels like 85% of your playtime in free-roam exploration, collecting resources and scanning various species of glowing fish—which, I must admit, are visually stunning with their bioluminescent displays. Then, when you finally trigger a story mission, the payoff feels disproportionately small. There's this one mission I recall vividly—it was just a cutscene, lasting maybe two minutes, with zero actual gameplay. My hands never left the controller except to set it down. While the visual spectacle was impressive, I couldn't help feeling shortchanged after the substantial time investment required to unlock it.

The characters themselves add another layer to this curious narrative approach. Daniel, the supposedly brash fellow diver who accompanies you occasionally, presents an interesting case study in character development—or lack thereof. His bravado quickly reveals itself as pure cowardice, which could have been an engaging character arc, but the game never really explores this dynamic beyond surface-level interactions. I found myself wanting to know more about him, why he puts up this facade, what drives him to dive despite his fears—but these threads never get properly developed across the 12 or so story missions I've completed.

Where the game truly shines, in my opinion, are those rare moments when it breaks from its established patterns. I'll never forget encountering the Celestial Ray for the first time—a massive, fantastical species that dwarfed my diver, its body shimmering with what appeared to be actual constellations. These moments of genuine wonder occur maybe three or four times throughout the entire experience, and they're so breathtaking that they almost make up for the otherwise lackluster narrative. The problem is they're spaced so far apart—I'd estimate 6-8 hours of gameplay between each significant discovery—that the overall pacing suffers dramatically.

Then there's the meta-story involving the ancient relic with its 99 slots to fill. On paper, this sounds like an engaging progression system. In practice, it feels more like a chore list than meaningful storytelling. You're essentially collecting artifacts scattered randomly throughout dives or completing achievement objectives—I've tracked about 47 different types of collectibles across my 35 hours of playtime. While completionists might appreciate having clear goals, the system does little to drive the narrative forward or provide substantial context for your actions. It's busywork disguised as storytelling, and after filling approximately 63 slots, I found my motivation waning significantly.

What's particularly fascinating from a game design perspective is how this structure affects player engagement. The free-roaming segments are actually quite meditative and enjoyable—swimming through kelp forests while schools of neon tetras dart past creates this almost therapeutic experience. But the abrupt transitions to brief, often underwhelming story missions create a jarring contrast that never quite finds its rhythm. I've spoken with other players who estimate spending upwards of 40 hours to complete all content, with only about 15% of that time dedicated to actual story progression.

If I were to suggest improvements, I'd recommend either shortening the free-roam requirements between story missions or significantly expanding the narrative content itself. The foundation is there—the underwater world is beautifully realized, the core diving mechanics are solid, and the visual design of the glowing fish species shows remarkable creativity. But the narrative execution feels undercooked, like a promising first draft rather than a fully realized story. There's a compelling game here, struggling to emerge from beneath the weight of its own structural choices. For now, it remains a beautiful diving simulator with narrative aspirations that never quite reach the surface.